Exhibits
Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme
Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme (in force prior to 5 January 2025)(opens in a new window)PDF 10.35 MBEnvironmental Management Overlay
Environmental Management Overlay of McCrae Landslide area(opens in a new window)PDF 798.75 KBGeotechnical Factual Report
Geotechnical Factual Report prepared by PSM(opens in a new window)PDF 23.97 MBPresentation prepared by Darren Paul
Presentation prepared by Darren Paul, WSP, for the Board of Inquiry into the McCrae landslide(opens in a new window)PDF 4.51 MBPhotograph of whiteboard, Darren Paul
Photograph of whiteboard written on by Darren Paul(opens in a new window)PDF 3.38 MB- Exhibit CA-5: Landslide Risk Assessment regarding 10-12 Viewpoint Road, McCrae prepared by PSM for Mornington Peninsula Shire Council dated 3 November 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 2.42 MBExhibit CA-6: Expert Opinion Report - Landslide Assessment in relation to 10-12 View Point Road prepared by PSM Consult Pty Ltd dated 11 June 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 8.35 MBExhibit CA-7: Expert Opinion Report regarding Rectification of 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae prepared by PSM Consult Pty Ltd dated 11 June 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 5.54 MBExhibit CA-8: Landslide Risk Assessment prepared by PSM for Mornington Peninsula Shire Council dated 11 June 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 4.95 MBExhibit CA-9: Stormwater and Sewer Investigation Proposal Reverse Brief prepared by PSM dated 17 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 827.88 KBExhibit CA-11(1): Witness Statement of Bulent Oz, Acting CEO of Mornington Peninsula Shire Council dated 11 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 3.11 MBExhibit CA-11(2): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Map of Affected Properties from November 2022 Landslide, dated 9 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 2.23 MBExhibit CA-11(5): Victorian Government Guidelines for preparing State, regional and Municipal Emergency Management Plans dated October 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 2.82 MBExhibit CA-11(6): Victorian State Emergency Management Plan, dated October 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 3.75 MBExhibit CA-11(7): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Coastal Landslip Assessment, dated 22 March 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 180.85 KBExhibit CA-11(8): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Inland Landslip Assessment dated 22 March 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 182.32 KBExhibit CA-11(9): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Landslide Susceptibility Map, dated November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 2.61 MBExhibit CA-11(10): Road Management Plan (Mornington Shire Council) 2022, dated 30 September 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 1.42 MBExhibit CA-11(11): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Asset Plan 2022-2032(opens in a new window)PDF 2.72 MBExhibit CA-11(12): Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning (DELWP) Committee of Managment Guidelines, dated December 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 1.72 MBExhibit CA-11(13): Building Order for Minor Works MW-145/21 issued to 597 Point Nepean Road , dated 18 August 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 262.19 KBExhibit CA-11-14 Email correspondence between Municipal Building Surveyor Mornington Shire Council and Nepean Building Permits and Consultants dated 17 August 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 169.91 KBExhibit CA-11(15): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Municipal Emergency Management Plan 2021-2024(opens in a new window)PDF 5.13 MBExhibit CA-11(16): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Emergency Management Plan 2021-2024(opens in a new window)PDF 5.24 MBExhibit CA-11-17 Mornington Peninsula Shire Council General Record of Inquiry regarding vegetation removal at 37 Cook Street dated 17 August 2020(opens in a new window)PDF 99.38 KBExhibit CA-11(18): Planning Scheme Contravention re earthworks at 599 Point Nepean Road dated 2 July 2018(opens in a new window)PDF 98.81 KBExhibit CA-11(20): Geotechnical Assessment of Regional Landslide Susceptibility, Mornington Peninsula Shire dated 18 July 2012(opens in a new window)PDF 2.38 MBExhibit CA-11(21): Landslip Flowchart prepared by Mornington Shire Council, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 115.36 KBExhibit CA-11(22): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Initial Notification and Assessment for Landslips, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 92.21 KBExhibit CA-11(23): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Landslip Flowchart, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 92.08 KBExhibit CA-11(24): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Table of Responsibilities, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 122.63 KB
- Exhibit CA-12(1): Witness Statement of David Simon (Acting Director Planning and Environment) dated 11 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 8.69 MBExhibit CA-12(2): Letter from Peninsula Planning Consultants Pty Ltd to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding redevelopment of for seven dwellings dated 17 March 2003(opens in a new window)PDF 205.86 KBExhibit CA-12(3): Bundle of scanned documents prepared by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council relating to 10-12 Viewpoint Road, McCrae, various dates(opens in a new window)PDF 7.29 MBExhibit CA-12(4): Colour & Material Schedule for 611-613 Point Nepean Road, McCrae prepared by Peter Hendy Design and Drafting Services, dated 4 September 2004(opens in a new window)PDF 2.16 MBExhibit CA-12(5): Application for a Planning Permit for 10-12 View Point Road dated 25 August 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 3.13 MBExhibit CA-12(6): Proposed renovations 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae prepared by JDA Architects dated 26 October 2015(opens in a new window)PDF 1.46 MBExhibit CA-12(7): Bundle of materials provided by Red Textas Building Surveyors to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council seeking building permit for 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae dated 16 March 2016(opens in a new window)PDF 17.28 MBExhibit CA-12(8): Letter from G Borghesi to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council requesting written feedback on proposal for construction of parking area at 10-12 View Point Road McCrae dated 29 August 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 72.41 KBExhibit CA-12(9): Email from N Stone of JDA Architects to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding Alterations and Amended Plan for 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae dated 21 September 2015(opens in a new window)PDF 736.9 KBExhibit CA-12(10): Engineering Approved Drainage Plan Image - Soakwell Detail dated 31 January 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 552.85 KBExhibit CA-12(11): Planning Permit for the Development of 5 Dwellings at 611-613 Point Nepean Road dated 3 September 2004(opens in a new window)PDF 2.1 MBExhibit CA-12(12): External Colour and Finishes Schedule - Architectural Plans for alterations and Additions to 10-12 View Point Road(opens in a new window)PDF 2.83 MBExhibit CA-12(13): Application to Amend a Planning Permit Under Secondary Consent for 10-12 View Point Road dated 4 December 2020(opens in a new window)PDF 215.84 KBExhibit CA-12(14): Application for Amendment to Planning Permit by Secondary Consent for 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae dated 4 December 2020(opens in a new window)PDF 212.49 KBExhibit CA-12(15): Handwritten note detailing construction around 10 View Point Road prepared by unidentified author dated 2 December 2020(opens in a new window)PDF 107.21 KBExhibit CA-12(16): Handwritten note with construction calculations for 10-12 View Point Road prepared by unknown author dated 2 December 2020(opens in a new window)PDF 195.33 KBExhibit CA-12(17): Handwritten document titled 'Proposed construction of deck' prepared by G Borghesi dated 4 December 2020(opens in a new window)PDF 194.07 KBExhibit CA-12(18): Proposed plan for construction of deck at 10 View Point Road, McCrae dated 2 December 2020(opens in a new window)PDF 116.42 KBExhibit CA-12(19): Email correspondence between CivilTest Pty Ltd and Meyer Consulting Pty Ltd regarding slope stability assessment for 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae dated 22 July 2015(opens in a new window)PDF 231.31 KBExhibit CA-12(20): Application for a Building Permit for property at 10-12 View Point Road dated 21 December 2015(opens in a new window)PDF 324.84 KBExhibit CA-12(21): Advice of Completion of Building Works at 611-615 Point Nepean Road and attachments dated 3 February 2006(opens in a new window)PDF 9.63 MBExhibit CA-12(22): Contract of Building Project Specifications for 611-615 Point Nepean Road dated 2 March 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 12.47 MBExhibit CA-12(23): Building Permit for 611-615 Point Nepean Road dated 15 April 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 1.09 MBExhibit CA-12(24): Planning Permit for 611-613 Point Nepean Road dated 12 May 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 588.93 KBExhibit CA-12(25): Conditional consent to issue building permit provided by United Energy Distribution dated 12 April 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 334.83 KBExhibit CA-12(26): Letter from VicRoads to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council consenting to subdivision of 611-613 Point Nepean Road, McCrae dated 1 April 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 322.09 KBExhibit CA-12(27): Letter from Origin Energy to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council consenting to subdivision dated 5 April 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 272.1 KBExhibit CA-12(28): Application for subdivision prepared by B Moxham and sent to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council on 22 March 205(opens in a new window)PDF 694.72 KBExhibit CA-12(29): Application for Planning Permit for 611-615 Point Nepean Road, McCrae dated 24 March 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 607.12 KBExhibit CA-12(30): Subdivision application checklist for 611-615 Point Nepean Road dated 24 March 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 1.05 MBExhibit CA-12(31): Certified plan of subdivision for 611 to 615 Point Nepean Road dated 15 June 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 1.87 MBExhibit CA-12(32): Advice by Licensed Surveyor confirming accuracy of subdivision plan and boundary dated 3 June 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 288.63 KBExhibit CA-12(33): Planning permit issued by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council for subdivision of land at 611-613 Point Nepean Road, McCrae dated 12 May 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 1.25 MBExhibit CA-12(34): Letter from Telstra to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council providing conditional consent to subdivision dated 2 May 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 353.6 KBExhibit CA-12(35): Letter from South East Water to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council consenting to subdivision dated 15 April 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 556.22 KBExhibit CA-12(36): Planning Permit for 611-613 Point Nepean Road dated 3 September 2004(opens in a new window)PDF 2.1 MBExhibit CA-12(37): Technical Memorandum prepared by Stantec for Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding Penny Lane, McCrae dated 7 December 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 2.71 MBExhibit CA-12(38): Expert Opinion Report - Landslide Assessment in relation to 10-12 View Point Road prepared by PSM Consult Pty Ltd dated 11 June 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 8.63 MBExhibit CA-12(39): Technical Memorandum prepared by Stantec in relation to review of Land Stability Assessment for Mornington Peninsula Shire Council dated 29 June 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 344.15 KBExhibit CA-12(40): Landslide Risk Assessment regarding 10-12 Viewpoint Road, McCrae prepared by PSM for Mornington Peninsula Shire Council dated 3 November 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 2.48 MBExhibit CA-12(41): Expert Opinion Report regarding Rectification of 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae prepared by PSM Consult Pty Ltd dated 11 June 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 5.87 MBExhibit CA-12(42): Landslide Risk Assessment prepared by PSM for Mornington Peninsula Shire Council dated 11 June 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 4.95 MBExhibit CA-12(43): Expert Opinion Report - Rectification prepared by PSM Consult Pty Ltd regarding 10-12 Viewpoint Road, McCrae dated 11 June 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 5.87 MBExhibit CA-12(44): Proposed Development plans for 10-12 Viewpoint Road prepared by JDA Architects dated 15 December 2015(opens in a new window)PDF 1.38 MBExhibit CA-12(45): Letter from Mornington Shire Council to Willigenburgs regarding Emergency Order to evacuate 3/613 Point Nepean Road dated 6 February 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 363.66 KBExhibit CA-12(46): Building Notice issued by Mornington Shire Council to Borghesis in relation to 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae dated 7 February 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 254.69 KBExhibit CA-12(47): Building Notice from Mornington Shire Council to Gerry and Bronwyn Borghesi requiring stabilisation works to be completed dated 7 February 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 253.44 KBExhibit CA-12(48): Planning Permit (P15/0321) for Removal of Vegetation at 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae dated 23 April 2015(opens in a new window)PDF 837.63 KBExhibit CA-12(49): Planning Permit approval for 10-12 Viewpoint Road, McCrae dated 15 December 2015(opens in a new window)PDF 98.31 KBExhibit CA-12(50): Application for an extension of a time to Planning Permit for 10 View Point Road, McCrae dated 21 March 2016(opens in a new window)PDF 1.78 MBExhibit CA-12(51): Building Notice to Gerry and Bronwyn Borghesi regarding 10-12 View Point Road dated 7 February 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 277.17 KBExhibit CA-12(52): Building Order issued in relation to 10-12 View Point Road requiring stabilisation work to landslip dated 4 April 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 243.88 KBExhibit CA-12(53): Building Order to 10-12 View Point Road requiring removal of landslip debris dated 4 April 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 244.23 KBExhibit CA-12(54): Emergency Order to address safety concerns and complete building work 10-12 View Point Road dated 18 May 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 246.59 KBExhibit CA-12(55): Building Notice BN-005/24 issued to 3/613 Point Nepean Road, dated 6 February 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 250.59 KBExhibit CA-12(56): Building Order BO-001/24 issued to 3/613 Point Nepean Road, dated 14 March 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 234.72 KBExhibit CA-12(57): Email correspondence between Mornington Shire Council and Cardno regarding Emergency Orders dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 466.62 KBExhibit CA-12(58): Email correspondence within Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding landslip at Penny Lane dated 18 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 126.7 KBExhibit CA-12(59): Letter from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to G Borghesi enclosing endorsed plans amended by secondary consent application dated 18 February 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 131.9 KBExhibit CA-12(60): Email correspondence within Mornington Shire Council regarding 16 November 2022 update on Penny Lane landslip(opens in a new window)PDF 798.14 KBExhibit CA-12(61): Email correspondence between Mornington Shire Council and Cardno regarding update on Emergency Order following 15 November 2022 landslip(opens in a new window)PDF 362.64 KBExhibit CA-12(62): Emergency Order issued by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to J McClean dated 24 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 224.63 KBExhibit CA-12(63): Letter from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Borghesi's regarding cancelling Emergency Order dated 30 March 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 127.69 KBExhibit CA-12(64): Emergency Order for 3/613 Point Nepean Road dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 1.32 MBExhibit CA-12(65): Letter from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Wells regarding cancellation of emergency order to 3 Penny Lane dated 18 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 109.99 KBExhibit CA-12(66): Initial Inspection Report of 3/613 Point Nepean Road McCrae dated 21 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 2.79 MBExhibit CA-12(67): Emergency Order for 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 1.35 MBExhibit CA-12(68): Initial Inspection Report for 2 Penny Lane dated 21 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 2.11 MBExhibit CA-12(69): Emergency Order issued to 14-16 View Point Road McCrae, dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 1.42 MBExhibit CA-12(70): Letter from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Borghesi's informing of the Emergency Order EO-144/22 cancellation at 10-12 View Point Road dated 18 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 125.43 KBExhibit CA-12(71): Building Order for Minor Works BNMW-127/23 issued to 10-12 View Point Road(opens in a new window)PDF 227.66 KBExhibit CA-12(72): Emergency Order Cancellation of EO-150/22 issued to 14-16 View Point Road(opens in a new window)PDF 175.34 KBExhibit CA-12(73): Emergency Order issued to occupants/owners of 3 Penny Lane, dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 378.63 KBExhibit CA-12(74): Emergency Order issued to 3/613 Point Nepean Road, dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 1.32 MBExhibit CA-12(75): Emergency Order EI-153/22 issued to 10-12 View Point Road, dated 28 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 218.67 KBExhibit CA-12(76): Emergency Order issued to 2 Penny Lane, dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 1.34 MBExhibit CA-12(77): Cancellation of Emergency Order EO-148/22 issued to 4/613 Point Nepean Road, dated 18 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 125.37 KBExhibit CA-12(78): Emergency Order EO-146/22 Cancellation issued to 2/613 Point Nepean Road(opens in a new window)PDF 120.64 KBExhibit CA-12(79): Emergency Order EO-152/22 issued to 10-2 View Point road, dated 18 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 778.91 KBExhibit CA-12(80): Emergency Order for U4/613 Point Nepean Road dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 1.3 MBExhibit CA-12(81) Emergency Order issued to 2/613 Point Nepean Road dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 1.3 MBExhibit CA-12(82): Initial Inspection Report of 10-12 View Point Road dated 21 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 1.4 MBExhibit CA-12(83): Cancellation of Emergency Order to 1/613 Point Nepean Road dated 18 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 123.3 KBExhibit CA-12(84): Emergency Order issued to 1/613 Point Nepean Rd, dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 1.33 MBExhibit CA-12(85): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Initial Inspection Report of 3/613 Point Nepean Road, McCrae dated 21 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 2.79 MBExhibit CA-12(86): Email correspondence within Mornington Shire Council regarding rain event on 14 November 2022, dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 200.45 KBExhibit CA-12(87): Handwritten incident form regarding landslip dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 586.24 KBExhibit CA-12(88): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme - Design and Development Overlay as at 31 July 2018(opens in a new window)PDF 136.59 KBExhibit CA-12(89): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme - Design and Development Overlay as at 22 July 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 164.92 KBExhibit CA-12(90): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme - Environmental Significance Overlay as at 31 July 2018(opens in a new window)PDF 155.31 KBExhibit CA-12(91): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme - Environmental Significance Overlay as at 22 July 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 122.47 KBExhibit CA-12(92): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme - General Residential Zone as at 31 July 2018(opens in a new window)PDF 230.45 KBExhibit CA-12(93): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme - General Residential Zone as at 22 July 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 101.07 KBExhibit CA-12(94): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme - Local Provision Map dated 9 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 324.05 KBExhibit CA-12(95): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Local Provision Map dated 14 January 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 497.47 KBExhibit CA-12(96): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme - Vegetation Protection Overlay as at 31 July 2018(opens in a new window)PDF 159.74 KBExhibit CA-12(97): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme - Vegetation Protection Overlay as at 22 July 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 116.23 KBExhibit CA-12(98): Land Register Search Statement (Title Search) for 10-12 View Point Road dated 8 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 48.05 KBExhibit CA-12(99): Register Search Statement (Title Search) for 2 Penny Lane dated 8 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 48.63 KBExhibit CA-12(100): Register Search Statement (Title Search) for 3/613 Point Nepean Road dated 8 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 34.23 KBExhibit CA-12(101): Planning Certificate for 2 Penny Lane dated 9 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 321.51 KBExhibit CA-12(102): Planning Certificate for 10-12 View Point Road dated 9 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 298.9 KBExhibit CA-12(103): Planning Certificate for 10-12 View Point Road dated 9 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 322.83 KBExhibit CA-12(104): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Amendment C17 Explanatory Report, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 133.71 KBExhibit CA-12(105): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Amendment C105 Explanatory Report, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 380.7 KBExhibit CA-12(106): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Amendment C271 Explanatory Report, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 182.27 KBExhibit CA-12(107): Letter from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to G Borghesi regarding refund of secondary consent application dated 10 August 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 190.6 KBExhibit CA-12(108): Application to Amend Planning Permit Under Secondary Consent for 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae dated 10 May 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 2.32 MBExhibit CA-12(109): Construction Officer Site Visit Initial Observations regarding Penny Lane landslip dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 1.18 MBExhibit CA-12(110): Call Receipt for Landslide at 3 Penny Lane dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 68.99 KBExhibit CA-12(111): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Review No.4 dated 19 November 2018(opens in a new window)PDF 3.99 MBExhibit CA-12(112): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Review No.5 of 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 2.33 MBExhibit CA-12(113): Email correspondence between Mornington Peninsula Shire Council and Downer Group regarding request for information from Board of Inquiry dated 8 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 173.78 KBExhibit CA-12(114): Letter from Downer to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding request for information from Board of Inquiry dated 9 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 89.8 KBExhibit CA-12(115): Deed of Novation between Downer EDI Works, Emoleum Roads Group and Mornington Peninsula Shire Council dated 30 June 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 818.78 KBExhibit CA-12(116): Deed of Extension and Variation between Downer EDI Works and Mornington Peninsula Shire dated 4 May 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 1.28 MBExhibit CA-12(117): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Safer Local Road Contract No 1218 with Emoleum dated 30 June 2006(opens in a new window)PDF 72.25 MBExhibit CA-12(118): Excel Spreadsheet detailing Invoices for Account 'K&C View Point Road McCrae', undated(opens in a new window)PDF 95.2 KBExhibit CA-12(119): Spreadsheet of Mornington Shire Council works completed in McCrae between 19 August 2016 to 14 March 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 146.41 KBExhibit CA-13(1): Second Witness Statement of David Simon, Acting Director (Planning and Environment) dated 17 April 2025 (also known as MSC.9000.0002.0031)(opens in a new window)PDF 17.99 MBExhibit CA-13(2): Technical Memorandum prepared by Stantec for Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding Penny Lane, McCrae dated 7 December 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 2.71 MBExhibit CA-13(3): Landslide Risk Assessment regarding 10-12 Viewpoint Road, McCrae prepared by PSM for Mornington Peninsula Shire Council dated 3 November 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 2.48 MBExhibit CA-13(4): Expert Opinion Report regarding Rectification of 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae prepared by PSM Consult Pty Ltd dated 11 June 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 5.87 MBExhibit CA-13(5): Landslide Risk Assessment prepared by PSM for Mornington Peninsula Shire Council dated 11 June 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 4.95 MBExhibit CA-13(6): Bundle of documents scanned by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council relating to 3 Penny Lane, McCrae, various dates(opens in a new window)PDF 48.13 MBExhibit CA-13(7): Objection to Planning Application P02/1833 6 View Point Road dated 10 September 2002(opens in a new window)PDF 198.82 KBExhibit CA-13(8): Covering note from Mike Salpeitro Drafting to D Quelch of Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding drawing sheets for 6 View Point Road, McCrae undated(opens in a new window)PDF 42.98 KBExhibit CA-13(9): Permit for works in relation to 6 View Point Road, McCrae dated 1 August 2003(opens in a new window)PDF 276.3 KBExhibit CA-13(10): Letter from R Stent to D Quelch of Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding planning application for 5 Viewpoint Road, dated 9 October 2002(opens in a new window)PDF 112.44 KBExhibit CA-13(11): Approved Amended Plans for Proposed Residence at 6 Viewpoint Road, McCrae prepared by e-Struct dated 22 August 2003(opens in a new window)PDF 459.34 KBExhibit CA-13(12): Submission from H Burrage to D Quelch of Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding planning permit for 6 View Point Road, McCrae dated 12 September 2002(opens in a new window)PDF 430 KBExhibit CA-13(13): Amended Site Plan for 6 Viewpoint Road, McCrae prepared by P.D.D.G dated 16 September 2002(opens in a new window)PDF 91.39 KBExhibit CA-13(14): Letter from C Pugh to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding placing site shed on nature strip at 6 View Point Road, McCrae dated 30 July 2003(opens in a new window)PDF 139.45 KBExhibit CA-13(15): Letter from H Burrage to D Quelch of Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding planning application for 6 View Point Road, McCrae dated 11 October 2002(opens in a new window)PDF 330.2 KBExhibit CA-13(16): Occupancy Permit for 6 View Point Road, McCrae dated 17 August 2006(opens in a new window)PDF 698.69 KBExhibit CA-13(17): Application to amend Planning Permit P02/1833 at 6 View Point Road, McCrae dated 25 August 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 668.29 KBExhibit CA-13(18): Site Plan for 6 View Point Road, McCrae dated 31 October 2002(opens in a new window)PDF 111.86 KBExhibit CA-13(19): Letter from John d'Helin to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding tree located at 6 View Point Road, McCrae, dated 14 November 2003(opens in a new window)PDF 190.31 KBExhibit CA-13(20): Building Permit for 2 View Point Road, McCrae dated 15 December 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 416.08 KBExhibit CA-13(21): Planning File for 3 Penny Lane, McCrae, scanned by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council, various dates(opens in a new window)PDF 14.46 MBExhibit CA-13(22): Copies of Plans for 6 View Point Road, McCrae, prepared by P.D.D.G, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 49.6 KBExhibit CA-13(23): Building Permit Application prepared by Nepean Building Permits for 2 View Point Road, McCrae dated 15 December 2003(opens in a new window)PDF 3.08 MBExhibit CA-13(24): Planning Certificate for 6 View Point Road, McCrae dated 31 January 2002(opens in a new window)PDF 493.62 KBExhibit CA-13(25): Bundle of scanned documents prepared by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council relating to 10-12 Viewpoint Road, McCrae, various dates(opens in a new window)PDF 7.29 MBExhibit CA-13(26): Letter from Moser Planning Services Pty Ltd to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding 6 View Point Road, McCrae dated 18 November 2002(opens in a new window)PDF 164.67 KBExhibit CA-13(27): Bundle of Mornington Peninsula Shire Council documents regarding 6 View Point Road, various dates(opens in a new window)PDF 16.38 MBExhibit CA-13(28): Letter from J d'Helin to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding planning application P02/1833 dated 17 September 2002(opens in a new window)PDF 157.52 KBExhibit CA-13(29): Proposed Development plans for 10-12 Viewpoint Road prepared by JDA Architects dated 15 December 2015(opens in a new window)PDF 1.38 MBExhibit CA-13(30): Letter to Western Port Building Design from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council providing copy of approved Planning Permit for 3 Penny Lane, McCrae dated 23 May 2012(opens in a new window)PDF 1.11 MBExhibit CA-13(31): Application for a Planning Permit for 10-12 View Point Road dated 25 August 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 3.13 MBExhibit CA-13(32): Application for Planning Permit for 6 View Point Road McCrae, dated 2 August 2002(opens in a new window)PDF 1.21 MBExhibit CA-13(33): Proposed renovations 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae prepared by JDA Architects dated 26 October 2015(opens in a new window)PDF 1.46 MBExhibit CA-13(34): Bundle of materials provided by Red Textas Building Surveyors to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council seeking building permit for 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae dated 16 March 2016(opens in a new window)PDF 17.28 MBExhibit CA-13(36): Planning Permit (P15/0321) for Removal of Vegetation at 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae dated 23 April 2015(opens in a new window)PDF 837.63 KBExhibit CA-13(37): Email from N Stone of JDA Architects to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding Alterations and Amended Plan for 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae dated 21 September 2015(opens in a new window)PDF 736.9 KBExhibit CA-13(38): Planning Permit approval for 10-12 Viewpoint Road, McCrae dated 15 December 2015(opens in a new window)PDF 98.31 KBExhibit CA-13(39): Application for an extension of a time to Planning Permit for 10 View Point Road, McCrae dated 21 March 2016(opens in a new window)PDF 1.78 MBExhibit CA-13(40): Emergency Order issued to 10-12 View Point Road McCrae dated 15 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 234.07 KBExhibit CA-13(41): Emergency Order for 10-12 View Point Road dated 17 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 266.61 KBExhibit CA-13(42): General Planning Enquiry by B Well of 3 Penny Lane to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding construction of fence dated 29 March 2011(opens in a new window)PDF 100.83 KBExhibit CA-13(43): General Planning Enquiry to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding construction of fence at 3 Penny Lane, McCrae dated 2 April 2012(opens in a new window)PDF 101.49 KBExhibit CA-13(44): Report to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding contravention of planning permit at 3 Penny Lane dated 16 December 2002(opens in a new window)PDF 104.69 KBExhibit CA-13(46): Application for Planning Permit for 3 Penny Lane, McCrae dated 27 April 2012(opens in a new window)PDF 2.26 MBExhibit CA-13(47): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council file note of attendance at 6 View Point Road dated 5 September 2005(opens in a new window)PDF 377.98 KBExhibit CA-13(49): Letter from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to G Borghesi enclosing endorsed plans amended by secondary consent application dated 18 February 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 131.9 KBExhibit CA-13(50): Construction plans for 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae, endorsed by Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme dated 18 February 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 191.13 KBExhibit CA-13(51): Letter from KWA to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council enclosing copy of Building Permit dated 16 July 2012(opens in a new window)PDF 160.49 KBExhibit CA-13(52): Building Permit for 3 Penny Lane, McCrae prepared by CivilTest Pty Ltd dated 15 June 1998(opens in a new window)PDF 1.21 MBExhibit CA-13(53): Letter from KWA to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council providing certificates for construction at 3 Penny Lane, McCrae dated 5 November 2012(opens in a new window)PDF 67.8 KBExhibit CA-13(54): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Significant Incident Notification regarding Landslip and Structural Damage in McCrae dated 7 January 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 407.06 KBExhibit CA-13(55): Email from PSM to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding preliminary landslide risk assessment at 3 Penny Lane, McCrae dated 7 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 124.24 KBExhibit CA-13(56): Building Permit for 2 View Point Road, McCrae dated 15 December 2003(opens in a new window)PDF 1.08 MBExhibit CA-13(57): Building Plans for construction of carport at 3 Penny Lane, McCrae dated June 2012(opens in a new window)PDF 1.95 MBExhibit CA-13(58): Certificate of Final Inspection for construction of carport at 3 Penny Lane, McCrae dated 2 November 2012(opens in a new window)PDF 226.47 KBExhibit CA-13(59): Building Permit for 3 Penny Lane, McCrae dated 16 July 2012(opens in a new window)PDF 475.86 KBExhibit CA-13(60): Proposed building plans for construction of carport at 3 Penny Lane, McCrae prepared by Western Port Building Design dated 1 June 2012(opens in a new window)PDF 2.07 MBExhibit CA-13(61): Building Notice issued to 3 Penny Lane, McCare dated 17 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 274.77 KBExhibit CA-13(62): Emergency Order issued to 6 View Point Road dated 17 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 220.76 KBExhibit CA-13(63): Bundle of drainage requests received by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council from November 2024 to April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 94.11 KBExhibit CA-13(64): JDA Architects plans for proposed development at 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae, endorsed by Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme dated 15 December 2015(opens in a new window)PDF 2.84 MBExhibit CA-13(65): Email correspondence chain between PSM and Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding preliminary landslide risk assessment of 3 Penny Lane, McCrae dated 7 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 195.92 KBExhibit CA-13(66): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Statutory Planning Assessment Process for Landslide Susceptible Areas (undated)(opens in a new window)PDF 712.01 KBExhibit CA-13(68): Geotechnical Factual Report prepared by PSM dated 9 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 25.01 MBExhibit CA-13(69): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Local Provision Map dated 9 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 424.71 KBExhibit CA-13(70): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme -Local Provision Map (undated)(opens in a new window)PDF 328.37 KBExhibit CA-13(71): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Local Provision Map, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 332.83 KBExhibit CA-13(72): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Local Provision Map dated 14 January 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 497.47 KBExhibit CA-13(74): Planning Certificate for 10-12 View Point Road dated 9 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 298.9 KBExhibit CA-13(75): Application to Amend a Planning Permit Under Secondary Consent for 10-12 View Point Road dated 4 December 2020(opens in a new window)PDF 215.84 KBExhibit CA-13(76): Application for Amendment to Planning Permit by Secondary Consent for 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae dated 4 December 2020(opens in a new window)PDF 212.49 KBExhibit CA-13(77): Handwritten note detailing construction around 10 View Point Road prepared by unidentified author dated 2 December 2020(opens in a new window)PDF 107.21 KBExhibit CA-13(78): Handwritten note with construction calculations for 10-12 View Point Road prepared by unknown author dated 2 December 2020(opens in a new window)PDF 195.33 KBExhibit CA-13(79): Geotechnical Investigation of Stability of Gully between The Eyrie & Point Nepean Road, McCrae prepared by LanePiper dated 3 September 2007(opens in a new window)PDF 8.83 MBExhibit CA-13(80): Draft report regarding Landslide Susceptibility Assessment prepared by Cardno LanePiper for Mornington Peninsula Shire Council dated 1 February 2012(opens in a new window)PDF 44.01 MBExhibit CA-13(81): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Table of Responsibilities relating to Planning Controls, Emergency Management Planning, Building Surveyor Management and Asset/infrastructure management, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 122.63 KBExhibit CA-13(82): Handwritten document titled 'Proposed construction of deck' prepared by G Borghesi dated 4 December 2020(opens in a new window)PDF 194.07 KBExhibit CA-13(83): Proposed plan for construction of deck at 10 View Point Road, McCrae dated 2 December 2020(opens in a new window)PDF 116.42 KBExhibit CA-13(84): Letter from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to G Borghesi regarding refund of secondary consent application dated 10 August 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 190.6 KBExhibit CA-13(85): Application to Amend Planning Permit Under Secondary Consent for 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae dated 10 May 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 2.32 MBExhibit CA-13(86): Email correspondence between CivilTest Pty Ltd and Meyer Consulting Pty Ltd regarding slope stability assessment for 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae dated 22 July 2015(opens in a new window)PDF 231.31 KBExhibit CA-13(88): Planning Certificate for 3 Penny Lane McCrae dated 9 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 311.67 KBExhibit CA-13(89): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Planning Scheme for Vegetation Protection Overlay listing exemptions for obtaining a permit, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 161.91 KBExhibit CA-13(90): Planning Certificate for 6 View Point Road, McCrae dated 15 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 278.64 KBExhibit CA-13(91): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Planning Scheme Schedule 25 to Clause 42.01 Environmental Significance Overlay, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 121.69 KBExhibit CA-13(92): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Planning Scheme Schedule 4 to Clause 43.02 Design and Development Overlay undated(opens in a new window)PDF 163.5 KBExhibit CA-13(93): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Planning Scheme Schedule 3 to Clause 43.2 Design and Development Overlay undated(opens in a new window)PDF 163.95 KBExhibit CA-13(94): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Planning Scheme Schedule 25 to Clause 42.01 Environmental Significance Overlay, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 122.63 KBExhibit CA-13(95): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Planning Scheme Design and Development Overlay outlining types of applications required, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 137.48 KBExhibit CA-13(96): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Schedule 3 to Clause 43.02 Design and Development Overlay undated(opens in a new window)PDF 163.64 KBExhibit CA-13(97): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Schedule 1 to Clause 32.08 General Residential Zone undated(opens in a new window)PDF 97.91 KBExhibit CA-13(98): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme General Residential Zone Permit requirements undated(opens in a new window)PDF 359.1 KBExhibit CA-13(99): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Schedule 1 to Clause 42.02 Vegetation Protection Overlay undated(opens in a new window)PDF 116.34 KBExhibit CA-13(100): Land Register Search Statement (Title Search) for 6 View Point Road, McCrae dated 15 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 35.3 KBExhibit CA-13(101): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Design and Development Overlay undated(opens in a new window)PDF 138.73 KBExhibit CA-13(102): Schedule 1 to Clause 42.02 of the Vegetation Protection Overlay, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 116.46 KBExhibit CA-13(103): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Schedule 1 to Clause 32.06 General Residential Zone undated(opens in a new window)PDF 101.9 KBExhibit CA-13(104): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Design and Development Overlay undated(opens in a new window)PDF 138.63 KBExhibit CA-13(105): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Vegetation Protection Overlay undated(opens in a new window)PDF 161.47 KBExhibit CA-13(106): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Environmental Significance Overlay undated(opens in a new window)PDF 158.09 KBExhibit CA-13(107): Letter from Hardwood Andrews to Dane Pope with updated letter of instruction dated 24 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 158.42 KBExhibit CA-13(108): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Planning Scheme Environmental Significance Overlay undated(opens in a new window)PDF 157.01 KBExhibit CA-13(109): Stormwater and Sewer Investigation Proposal Reverse Brief prepared by PSM dated 17 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.53 MBExhibit CA-13(110): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme General Residential Zone Schedule 1 undated(opens in a new window)PDF 98.05 KBExhibit CA-13(111): Letter from PSM to Harwood Andrews Regarding Draft Fee Proposal for Geotechnical and Groundwater Investigation of McCrae Landslide dated 6 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.83 MBExhibit CA-13(112): Aerial image of Exclusion Area Annotated by PSM with Proposed Geotechnical and Groundwater Investigation Plan dated 6 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 904.83 KBExhibit CA-13(114): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Residential Zone undated(opens in a new window)PDF 361.8 KBExhibit CA-13(115): Letter of Instruction from Harwood Andrews to PSM regarding Waterflow at Coburn Avenue, McCrae dated 23 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 124.98 KBExhibit CA-13(116): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme General Residential Zone undated(opens in a new window)PDF 349.77 KBExhibit CA-13(117): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Vegetation Protection Overlay undated(opens in a new window)PDF 162.02 KBExhibit CA-13(118): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Environmental Significance Overlay undated(opens in a new window)PDF 158.07 KBExhibit CA-13(119): Mornington Peninsula Planning Scheme Schedule 25 to Clause 42.01 Environmental Significance Overlay undated(opens in a new window)PDF 122.52 KBExhibit CA-13(120): Emergency Order issued to 6 View Point Road, McCrae dated 20 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 577.34 KBExhibit CA-13(121): Emergency Order issued to 605 Point Nepean Road, McCrae dated 14 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 541.7 KBExhibit CA-13(122): Emergency Order to 10-12 View Point Road, McCrae dated 20 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 568.03 KBExhibit CA-13(123): Application for Building Permit at 3 Penny Lane, McCrae dated 31 May 2012(opens in a new window)PDF 565.74 KBExhibit CA-13(124): Work Order request completed by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding remediation of pooling water at 121 Austin Avenue, McCrae dated 1 June 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 100.28 KBExhibit CA-13(125): Work Order request for inspection of storm water drains near 563 Point Nepean Road, McCrae dated 29 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 96.82 KBExhibit CA-13(126): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Customer Request regarding water pooling out front of 195 Bayview Road, dated 19 July 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 102.84 KBExhibit CA-13(127): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Road Maintenance Request regarding Potholes and Erosion at Bayview Road, McCrae dated 22 November 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 78.54 KBExhibit CA-13(128): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Request for Inspection of Pooling Water at 195 Bayview Road, McCrae dated 22 February 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 97.5 KBExhibit CA-13(129): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Request for Investigation into Lack of Stormwater Drains near 563 Point Nepean Road, McCrae dated 17 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 100.99 KBExhibit CA-13(130): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Work Order Request for Remediation of Sink Hole at 36 Arthurs Avenue, McCrae dated 2 March 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 95.14 KBExhibit CA-13(131): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Customer Request Regarding Investigation of Pooling Water on Driveway at 121 Austin Avenue, McCrae dated 23 February 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 102.95 KBExhibit CA-13(132): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Customer Request Regarding Investigation of Rising Water in Road at 16 Chunar Grove, McCrae dated 6 July 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 102.91 KBExhibit CA-13(134): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Request to Investigate Stormwater Pipe in front of 17 Beverley Road, McCrae dated 7 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 102.36 KBExhibit CA-13(135): Letter from KWA to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Lodging Building Permit for 3 Penny Lane, McCrae dated 17 July 2012(opens in a new window)PDF 81.93 KBExhibit CA-13(137): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Work Order Request for Stormwater Drainage Concern at 721-723 Point Nepean Road, McCrae dated 17 August 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 67.05 KBExhibit CA-13(138): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Work Order Request for Blocked Stormwater Drain located at 2 Somers Close, McCrae dated 8 February 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 107.4 KBExhibit CA-13(139): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Work Order Request for contact to 2 Penny Lane regarding update following 2022 landslip, dated 24 May 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 95.58 KBExhibit CA-13(140): Certificate of Compliance of design for 3 Penny Lane, McCrae completed by J Varkulevicius dated 29 June 2012(opens in a new window)PDF 217.78 KBExhibit CA-13(141): Work Order request for investigation of water flow at 1 Beverley Road, McCrae dated 11 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 103 KBExhibit CA-13(142): Email from Victoria State Emergency Service to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding establishment of exclusion zones dated 17 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 156.27 KBExhibit CA-13(143): Email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to South East Water requesting investigation of sunken hole in nature strip at 31 Riley Street, McCrae dated 12 July 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 1010.9 KBExhibit CA-13(144): Email from D Perera of Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to unidentified individual regarding investigations ongoing to determine source of water leak at Coburn Ave, McCrae dated 23 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 166.55 KBExhibit CA-13(146): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council General Enquiry Request to call resident of 20 Cairn Road McCrae to discuss concerns relating to construction dated 27 November 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 80.01 KBExhibit CA-13(147): Work Order request for investigation of blocked stormwater drain at 16 Austin Avenue, McCrae dated 8 February 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 65.89 KBExhibit CA-13(148): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Work Order request for investigation into blocked stormwater drain at 14 Rudduck Street, McCrae dated 12 April 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 62.08 KBExhibit CA-13(149): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Work Order Request for investigation of blocked stormwater drain at 1 Hillman Avenue, McCrae dated 19 April 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 65.49 KBExhibit CA-13(150): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Work Order relating to Stormwater Drainage Concern at 1/16 Chunar Grove, McCrae dated 24 April 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 79.06 KBExhibit CA-13(151): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Work Order Request regarding Stormwater Drainage Concern at 41 Hillman Avenue dated 19 June 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 77.27 KBExhibit CA-13(152): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Work Order Request regarding Stormwater Drainage Concern at 1/16 Chunar Grove, McCrae dated 10 July 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 68.01 KBExhibit CA-13(153): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Work Order Stormwater Drainage Concern at 16 Burrell Street, McCrae dated 5 October 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 66.6 KBExhibit CA-13(154): Work Order request for investigation into wet nature strip at 9 Catherine Street, McCrae dated 16 October 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 78.88 KBExhibit CA-13(155): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Work Order request for repair of sinkhole on road at 3 Charlesworth St, McCrae dated 28 November 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 65.78 KBExhibit CA-13(156): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Work Order request for investigation of full stormwater drain at 2 Penny Lane, McCrae dated 16 December 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 63.08 KBExhibit CA-13(157): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Request for Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to contact resident of 1 Charlesworth St, McCrae to provide update on status of road lifting dated 17 December 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 78.68 KBExhibit CA-13(158): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Work Order Request for Investigation into Stormwater Drainage Concern at 1 Charlesworth Street, McCrae dated 20 December 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 67.61 KBExhibit CA-13(159): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council General Inquiry from resident of 1 Charlesworth Street, McCrae complaining of water pooling dated 7 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 69.82 KBExhibit CA-13(160): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council McCrae Landslide Enquiry regarding water egress at 1 Waller Place, McCrae dated 31 December 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 64.31 KBExhibit CA-13(161): Response from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to unidentified resident regarding stormwater drainage concern at 1 Waller Place, McCrae dated 12 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 55.98 KBExhibit CA-13(162): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Landslide Enquiry regarding water flowing out of road near Charlesworth Street dated 12 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 68.22 KBExhibit CA-13(163): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Briefing Paper regarding Erosion Management overlays and Future Options dated 15 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 22.28 MBExhibit CA-13(164): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Work Order request for investigation of cause of water leak at 189 Bayview Road, McCrae dated 5 April 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 99.58 KBExhibit CA-13(165): Mornington Peninsula Shire Work Order Request for repair of collapsed stormwater pit dated 19 June 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 103.78 KBExhibit CA-14(1): Third Witness Statement of David Simon dated 7 May 2025 (also known as MSC.9000.0002.0001)(opens in a new window)PDF 338.26 KBExhibit CA-14(2): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Significant Incident Notification regarding Landslip and Structural Damage in McCrae dated 7 January 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 407.06 KBExhibit CA-14(3): Email from PSM to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding preliminary landslide risk assessment at 3 Penny Lane, McCrae dated 7 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 124.24 KBExhibit CA-14(4): Email correspondence within Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding site inspection at McCrae Landslide to investigate drainage network dated 14 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 167.55 KBExhibit CA-14(5): Email notification to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding incident assessment at 3 Penny Lane, McCrae dated 14 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 178.2 KBExhibit CA-14(6): Crisis Leadership Team Meetings Summary of Actions 2022 and 2025 in relation to McCrae landslide incident(opens in a new window)PDF 1.2 MBExhibit CA-14(7): Recovery Communication update email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to residents of the McCrae area dated 23 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 91.65 KBExhibit CA-14(8): Recovery Communication update email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to residents of the McCrae area dated 23 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 107.89 KBExhibit CA-14(9): Recovery Communication update email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to residents of the McCrae area dated 24 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 141.2 KBExhibit CA-14(10): Recovery Communication update email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to residents of the McCrae area dated 28 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 140.09 KBExhibit CA-14(11): Recovery Communication update email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to residents of the McCrae area dated 29 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 141.76 KBExhibit CA-14(12): Recovery Communication update email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to residents of the McCrae area dated 30 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 100.75 KBExhibit CA-14(13): Recovery Communication update email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to residents of the McCrae area dated 31 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 128.41 KBExhibit CA-14(14): Recovery Communication update email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to residents of the McCrae area dated 3 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 131.31 KBExhibit CA-14(15): Recovery Communication update email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to residents of the McCrae area dated 4 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 134.24 KBExhibit CA-14(16): Recovery Communication update email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to residents of the McCrae area dated 6 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 127.35 KBExhibit CA-14(17): Recovery Communication update email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to residents of the McCrae area dated 8 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 114.51 KBExhibit CA-14(18): Recovery Communication update email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to residents of the McCrae area dated 10 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 105.38 KBExhibit CA-14(19): Recovery Communication update email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to residents of the McCrae area dated 11 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 138 KBExhibit CA-14(20): Recovery Communication update email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to residents of the McCrae area dated 13 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 103.32 KBExhibit CA-14(21): Recovery Communication update email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to residents of the McCrae area dated 18 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 199.05 KBExhibit CA-14(22): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council McCrae Landslide Summary of Events, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 820.44 KBExhibit CA-14(23): Mornington Peninsula Shire aerial map of exclusion area dated 20 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 652.5 KBExhibit CA-14(24): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council resident update regarding McCrae Landslide dated 17 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 124.75 KBExhibit CA-14(25): Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Operational and Repatriation Plan dated 14 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 203.94 KBExhibit CA-14(26): Appendix 1 to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Operational and Repatriation Plan dated 14 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 76.82 KBExhibit CA-14(27): Map of McCrae Exclusion area including details of fencing prepared by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council dated 17 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 733.83 KBExhibit CA-14(28): Appendix 2 of Mornington Peninsula Shire Council Operational and Repatriation Plan dated 14 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 715.68 KBExhibit CA-14(29): Statement from the Mayor of Mornington Peninsula Shire Council dated 14 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 92.39 KBExhibit CA-14(30): Handwritten notes from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council dated 14 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 690.7 KBExhibit CA-14(31): Residents update issued by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding Board of Inquiry dated 18 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 121.56 KBExhibit CA-14(32): Residents update issued by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding landslide recovery dated 11 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 155.84 KBExhibit CA-14(33): Residents update regarding landslide recovery dated 4 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 124.55 KBExhibit CA-14(34): Letter from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Minister for Emergency Services and Natural Disaster Recovery dated 21 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 190.32 KBExhibit CA-14(35): Southern Peninsula Community Support statement regarding financial difficulty, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 84.94 KBExhibit CA-14(36): Victorian Government contacts list (Ministers and members), undated(opens in a new window)PDF 58.42 KBExhibit CA-14(37): Residents update issued by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding landslide recovery, dated 7 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 154.89 KBExhibit CA-14(38): Letter to Minister for Emergency Services from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding request for support dated 19 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 171.22 KBExhibit CA-14(39): Residents update regarding monitoring data and geotechnical updates dated 14 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 113.92 KBExhibit CA-14(40): Displacement monitoring data collected between 13 February 2025 and 27 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 11.09 MBExhibit CA-14(41): Statement from Mayor issued by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council with update regarding landslide, dated 21 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 129.5 KBExhibit CA-14(42): Victorian Government Gazette Order in Council establishing the Board of Inquiry into the McCrae landslide dated 18 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 317.78 KBExhibit CA-14(43): Residents update issued by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding geotechnical update and Board of Inquiry, dated 21 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 126.01 KBExhibit CA-14(44): Displacement monitoring data prepared by PSM Consult Pty Ltd collected between 27 February 2025 and 6 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 6.01 MBExhibit CA-14(45): Statement from Mayor issued by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding landslide update, dated 15 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 110.92 KBExhibit CA-14(46): Residents update from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding emergency orders, dated 21 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 154.26 KBExhibit CA-14(47): Statement from Mayor issued by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding lifting of emergency orders, dated 21 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 77.9 KBExhibit CA-14(48): Letter from South East Water to residents regarding re-entry to homes, dated 14 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 198.01 KBExhibit CA-14(49): Monitoring - GPS Sensor System and LiDAR data in Community update dated 28 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.13 MBExhibit CA-14(50): Residents update issued by the Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding McCrae landslide recovery, dated 28 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 143.73 KBExhibit CA-14(51): Proposed borehole locations for piezometer, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 344.47 KBExhibit CA-14(52): Residents update in relation to McCrae landslide recovery issued by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council dated 28 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 129.09 KBExhibit CA-14(53): Displacement Monitoring Data prepared by PSM Consult Pty Ltd collected between 7 March 2025 and 13 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 7.21 MBExhibit CA-14(54): Community update to McCrae residents dated 20 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 340.4 KB
Witness Statement - Kellie Moran
Exhibit CA-15(1): Witness Statement of Kellie Moran, signed 12 May 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 545.14 KBTitle Search - 3 Penny Lane, McCrae
Exhibit CA-15(2) and Exhibit CA-16(3): Exhibit KM-1 and Exhibit NM-2 - Title Search of 3 Penny Lane, McCrae dated 7 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 101.48 KBPhotograph - 3 Penny Lane, McCrae
Exhibit CA-15(3): Exhibit KM-2 - Photograph of damage to laundry and hallway at 3 Penny Lane, taken 5 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 64.4 KBMornington Peninsula Shire Council Report
Exhibit CA-15(4) and Exhibit CA-16(9): Exhibit KM-3 and NM-8 - Report from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding Owners Action items for 3 Penny Lane and 10-12 View Point Road, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 972.69 KBWitness Statement - Nicholas Moran
Exhibit CA-16(1): Witness Statement of Nicholas James Moran, signed 12 May 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 621.96 KBFloorplan - 3 Penny Lane, McCrae
Exhibit CA-16(2): Exhibit NM-1 - Floorplan of 3 Penny Lane, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 310.98 KBEmail - Belle Property to Nicholas Moran
Exhibit CA-16(4) Exhibit NM-3 - Email from Belle Property Dromana to Nicholas Moran regarding Penny Lane/View Point Road drainage issues, dated 5 March 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 200.66 KBTitle Search - 3 Penny Lane, McCrae
Exhibit CA-16(5): Exhibit NM-4 - Title Search of 3 Penny Lane dated 14 March 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 1.63 MBText Messages - Nicholas Moran to Matt Grover
Exhibit CA-16(7): Exhibit NM-6 - Text messages from Nicholas Moran to Matt Grover enclosing screenshots of social media posts, dated 8 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 164.6 KBText Messages - Nicholas Moran to RACV
Exhibit CA-16(8): Exhibit NM-7 - Text messages between Nicholas Moran and RACV enclosing photographs, dated 9 and 11 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 482.46 KBText Messages - Gerrard Borghesi and Nicholas Moran
Exhibit CA-16(10): Exhibit NM-9 - Text messages between Gerrard Borghesi and Nicholas Moran regarding access to property, dated 9 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 97.55 KBText Messages - Nicholas Moran and RACV
Exhibit CA-16(11): Exhibit NM-10 - Text message thread between Nicholas Moran and RACV regarding diversion fix, dated 11 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 442.59 KBWitness Statement - Brett Cooper
Exhibit CA-17(1): Witness Statement of Brett Cooper, signed 12 May 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 426.88 KBPhotograph - Charlesworth Street
Exhibit CA-17(2): Exhibit BC-1: Photograph of workers on Charlesworth Street, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 498.61 KBCommunity update - South East Water
Exhibit CA-17(3): Exhibit BC-2: Community update from South East Water dated 17 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 534.19 KBEmail - Brett Cooper to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council
Exhibit CA-17(4): Exhibit BC-3: Email from Brett Cooper to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council enclosing correspondence with Councillor Max Patton, dated 23 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 129.34 KBEmail - Brett Cooper and Sam Groth MP
Exhibit CA-17(5): Exhibit BC-4: Email correspondence between Brett Cooper and Sam Groth MP, dated 23 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 203.65 KBPhotograph - South East Water on Charlesworth and Waller Place
Exhibit CA-17(6): Exhibit BC-5: Photograph of SEW on Charlesworth and Waller Place, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 438.84 KBEmail - Brett Cooper and South East Water
Exhibit CA-17(7): Exhibit BC-6: Email correspondence between Brett Cooper and Chris Ransom, South East Water dated 13 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 161.14 KBEmail - Brett Cooper and South East Water
Exhibit CA-17(8): Exhibit BC-7: Email correspondence between Brett Cooper and South East Water dated 21 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 229.6 KBDraft Sand Survey
Exhibit SEW-1: Draft Sand Survey map provided by South East Water dated May 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 746.11 KBWitness Statement - Kevin Hutchings
Exhibit CA-18(1): Witness Statement of Kevin Barry Hutchings, signed 12 May 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.12 MBPhotograph - Borghesi property
Exhibit CA-18(2): Exhibit KH-1 - Photograph of Borghesi property taken by Kevin Hutchings on 7 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.09 MBFlyer - South East Water
Exhibit CA-18(5): Exhibit KH-4 - South East Water flyer titled 'Community update - Supporting our customers in McCrae' dated 17 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 427.41 KBSouth East Water map
Exhibit CA-18(6): Exhibit KH-5 - Screenshot from SEW map, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 506.54 KBMinutes - McCrae Landslide Community Meeting
Exhibit CA-18(7): Exhibit KH-6 - Minutes of McCrae Landslide Community Meeting provided by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council, dated 22 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 154.64 KBEmail - South East Water
Exhibit CA-18(8): Exhibit KH-7 - Screenshot of email from South East Water regarding water leak issue at 3 Charlesworth Street, dated 24 November 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 223.98 KBPhotograph - burst site
Exhibit CA-18(9): Exhibit KH-8 - Photograph of burst site taken by Kevin Hutchings on 7 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 298.76 KBPhotograph - Waller Place intersection
Exhibit CA-18(10): Exhibit KH-9 - Photograph of intersection at Waller Place taken by Kevin Hutchings on 7 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 235.1 KBPhotograph - Coburn intersection
Exhibit CA-18(11): Exhibit KH-10 - Photograph of the intersection at Coburn Intersection taken by Kevin Hutchings on 7 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 289.53 KBPhotograph - burst site
Exhibit CA-18(12): Exhibit KH-11 - Photograph of Burst Site taken by Kevin Hutchings on 14 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 236.3 KBSouth East Water maps
Exhibit CA-18(16): Exhibit KH-15 - Maps downloaded from SEW map by Kevin Hutchings on 24 February 2025 and 6 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 943.92 KBPhotograph - Coburn intersection
Exhibit CA-18(17): Exhibit KH-16 - Photograph of road at Coburn Intersection taken by Jo Thompson, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 245.23 KBPhotograph - Coburn intersection
Exhibit CA-18(18): Exhibit KH-17 - Photograph of road at Coburn Intersection taken by Jo Thompson, 27 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 330.2 KBReport - Civiltest
Exhibit CA-18(19): Exhibit KH-18 - Report of Civiltest dated 29 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 497.66 KBVideo exhibits
Video - 3 Penny Lane, McCrae
Video - 3 Penny Lane, McCrae
Video - Borghesi property
Video - Charlesworth Street, Waller Place intersection
Video - burst site
Exhibit CA-18(13): Exhibit KH-12 - Video of Burst Site taken by Kevin Hutchings on 27 February 2025
Video - burst site
Exhibit CA-18(14): Exhibit KH-13 - Video of Burst Site taken by Kevin Hutchings on 27 February 2025
Video - burst site
Exhibit CA-18(15): Exhibit KH-14 - Video of Burst Site taken by Kevin Hutchings on 27 February 2025
Witness Statement - John Bolch
Exhibit CA-19(1): Witness Statement of John Bolch, signed 14 May 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.17 MBPhotographs - 14 January, 2025
Exhibit CA-19(3): Exhibit JB-2: Photographs taken on 14 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.35 MBPhotographs - Coburn intersection
Exhibit CA-19(6): Exhibit JB-5: Photographs taken of Coburn intersection on 15 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 2.53 MBPhotographs - Waller intersection
Exhibit CA-19(7): Exhibit JB-6: Photographs taken of works at Waller intersection on 15 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.82 MBPhotograph - Prospect Hill Road kerbs
Exhibit CA-19(10): Exhibit JB-9: Photograph taken of kerbs along Prospect Hill Road on 15 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 780.42 KBPhotograph - Waller intersection
Exhibit CA-19(14): Exhibit JB-13: Photograph taken of workers at Waller intersection on 24 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 282.91 KBPhotographs - Coburn intersection
Exhibit CA-19(15): Exhibit JB-14: Photographs taken at Coburn intersection on 24 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.23 MBPhotographs - water assets
Exhibit CA-19(16): Exhibit JB-15: Photographs taken of water assets on 14 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.09 MBPhotograph - Boulevard culvert
Exhibit CA-19(17): Exhibit JB-16: Photograph taken of culvert on Boulevard reserve on 14 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 3.86 MBPhotograph - burst site
Exhibit CA-19(18): Exhibit JB-17: Photographs taken of area near burst site on 20 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 3.86 MBEmail - Mornington Peninsula Shire to Paul Willigenburg
Exhibit CA-21 (3): PW-10: Email correspondence from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Paul Willigenburg and others regarding timing of works, dated 20 December 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 175.99 KBPhotographs - Coburn intersection
Exhibit CA-19(22): Exhibit JB-21: Photographs taken of Coburn intersection on 27 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.65 MBPhotographs - Moran property
Exhibit CA-19(23): Exhibit JB-22: Photographs taken of Moran property on 28 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 2.78 MBAnnotated map
Exhibit CA-19(24): Exhibit JB-23: Copy of annotated map prepared by John Bolch, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 468.98 KBScreenshot - text message and photographs
Exhibit CA-19(25): Exhibit JB-24: Screenshot of text message with Mr Rotter and photographs taken on 7 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 4.29 MBPhotographs - repair site
Exhibit CA-19(26): Exhibit JB-25: Photographs taken of repair site on 8 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 5.51 MBPhotographs - testing equipment
Exhibit CA-19(27): Exhibit JB-26: Photographs taken of testing equipment on 27 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 5.51 MBPhotographs - burst site
Exhibit CA-19(28): Exhibit JB-27: Photographs taken of burst site, kerb, stormwater along Bayview Road taken 27 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 5.08 MBPhotographs - kerbs and channel
Exhibit CA-19(30): Exhibit JB-29: Photographs taken of kerbs and channel along Prospect Hill Road on 11 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 2.37 MBFire Fighting Diagnostic Inspection Report
Exhibit CA-19(31): Exhibit JB-30: Fire Fighting Diagnostic Inspection Report prepared by Fair Fire Services dated 12 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 160.32 KBPressure and Flow Information Report - South East Water
Exhibit CA-19(32): Exhibit JB-31: Pressure and Flow Information Report prepared by South East Water dated 27 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 603.29 KBReport - Outlook Road, McCrae
Exhibit CA-19(33): Exhibit JB-32: Report prepared by A. Christofi titled Outlook Road McCrae dated 23 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.45 MBPhotograph - pipe
Exhibit CA-20: Photograph of pipe provided by John Bolch during evidence on 14 May 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 200.7 KBWitness Statement - Paul Willigenburg
Exhibit CA-21(1): Witness Statement of Paul Willigenburg, signed 14 May 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1 MBPhotograph - 3/613 Point Nepean Road
Exhibit CA-21(2): PW-01 - Photograph of the front of Unit 3, 613 Point Nepean Rd taken on 30 April 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 279.34 KBPhotograph - Emergency Order
Exhibit CA-21(4): PW-03 - Photograph of the Emergency Order issued by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding Unit 3/613 Point Nepean Road, McCrae dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 3.06 MBPhotographs - backyard
Exhibit CA-21(5): PW-04 - 2 x photographs of the backyard of property, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 1.15 MBEmail - Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Paul Willigenburg
Exhibit CA-21(6): PW-05 - Email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Paul Willigenburg regarding Emergency order, dated 1 December 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 169.57 KBEmail - Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Paul Willigenburg
Exhibit CA-21(7): PW-06 - Email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Paul Willigenburg regarding geotechnical report from Civiltest Pty Ltd, dated 5 December 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 132.28 KBEmail - Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Paul Willigenburg
Exhibit CA-21(8): PW-07 - Email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Paul Willigenburg regarding geotechnical reports received, dated 7 December 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 137.45 KBEmail - Paul Willigenburg to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council
Exhibit CA-21(9): PW-08 - Email from Paul Willigenburg to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding works plan review, dated 20 December 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 80.28 KBEmail - Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Paul Willigenburg
Exhibit CA-21(10): PW-09 - Email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Paul Willigenburg regarding Civiltest three-stage plan, dated 20 December 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 175.99 KBEmail - Paul Willigenburg to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council
Exhibit CA-21(12): PW-11 - Email from Paul Willigenburg to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding frustration as to landslip, dated 22 December 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 60.03 KBEmail - Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Paul Willigenburg
Exhibit CA-21(13): PW-12 - Email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Paul Willigenburg regarding works at McCrae, dated 23 December 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 120.17 KBEmail - Paul Willigenburg to CHU
Exhibit CA-21(14): PW-13 - Email from Paul Willigenburg to CHU regarding questions from residents, dated 4 February 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 67.05 KBEmail - Paul Willigenburg to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council
Exhibit CA-21(15): PW-14 - Email from Paul Willigenburg to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding peer review of 3 stage plan, dated 13 February 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 472.29 KBEmail - Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Paul Willigenburg
Exhibit CA-21(16): PW-15 - Email from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Paul Willigenburg regarding completion of peer review, dated 14 February 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 137.5 KBEmail - Mornington Peninsula Shire Council and Paul Willigenburg
Exhibit CA-21(17): PW-16 - Email correspondence between Mornington Peninsula Shire Council and Paul Willigenburg regarding drainage issues at Viewpoint Road and Penny Lane, dated 17 February 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 91.59 KBEmail - Mornington Peninsula Shire Council and Paul Willigenburg, John d'Helin and Jon McClean
Exhibit CA-21(18): PW-17 - Email correspondence between Mornington Peninsula Shire Council and Paul Willigenburg, John d'Helin and Jon McClean regarding update on drainage issues, dated 21 February 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 160.84 KBEmail - Mornington Peninsula Shire Council and Paul Willigenburg, John d'Helin and Jon McClean
Exhibit CA-21(19): PW-18 - Email correspondence between Mornington Peninsula Shire Council and Paul Willigenburg, John d'Helin and Jon McClean regarding drainage works, dated 1 March 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 135.83 KBEmail - Mornington Peninsula Shire Council and Paul Willigenburg
Exhibit CA-21(20): PW-19 - Email correspondence between Mornington Peninsula Shire Council and Paul Willigenburg regarding progress of main works, dated 20 December 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 209.25 KBEmail - CHU to Paul Willigenburg
Exhibit CA-21(21): PW-20 - Email from CHU to Paul Willigenburg and Jon McClean regarding geotechnical reports, dated 5 May 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 178.06 KBLetter - McGuinness Legal to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council
Exhibit CA-21(22): PW-21 - Letter from McGuinness Legal to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding Paul and Denise Willigenburg dated 12 July 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 750.58 KBLetter - McGuinness Legal to RACV
Exhibit CA-21(23): PW-22 - Letter from McGuinness Legal to RACV regarding Paul and Denise Willigenburg and access to documents dated 25 July 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 529.77 KBLetter - McGuinness Legal to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council
Exhibit CA-21(24): PW-23 - Letter from McGuinness Legal to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council advising that Willigenburgs return to property, dated 7 September 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 138.85 KBLetter - Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Willigenburgs
Exhibit CA-21(25): PW-24 - Letter from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Willigenburgs regarding request for access, dated 1 February 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 253.7 KBSigned Consent - Paul Willigenburg
Exhibit CA-21(26): PW-25 - Signed consent to exercise powers of entry from Paul Willigenburg dated 5 February 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 347.23 KBLetter - Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Willigenburgs
Exhibit CA-21(27): PW-26 - Letter from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Willigenburgs enclosing Emergency Order, dated 6 February 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 255.66 KBLetters - Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Willigenburgs
Exhibit CA-21(28): PW-27 - Letters from Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Willigenburgs enclosing Emergency Orders dated 20, 24, 26, 28 February 2024, 3, 12 March 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 458.54 KBEmergency Orders - Mornington Peninsula Shire Council to Willigenburgs
Exhibit CA-21(29): PW-28 - Emergency Orders made by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council issued to Willigenburgs dated 20 February 2024, 3 March 2024 and 12 March 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 273.39 KBGeotechnical Opinion Report - A.S. James
Exhibit CA-21(30): PW-29 - Geotechnical Opinion Report (Collaborative Approach) prepared by A.S. James Pty Ltd dated 24 July 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 10.04 MBEmail - Mornington Peninsula Shire Council and Paul Willigenburg
Exhibit CA-21(31): PW-30 - Email correspondence between Mornington Peninsula Shire Council and Paul Willigenburg regarding drainage concern and photographs, dated 16 December 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 450.99 KBOwners Action Items - issued by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council
Exhibit CA-21(32): PW-31 - Owners Action Items in relation to 3 Penny Lane and 10-12 View Point Road issued by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council, dated January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 2.34 MBWitness Statement - Gerrard Borghesi
Exhibit CA-22(1): Witness Statement of Gerrard Raymond Borghesi, signed 14 May 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 328.12 KBAnnexures to Gerrard Borghesi Witness Statement
Annexures to Gerrard Borghesi Witness Statement(opens in a new window)PDF 6.18 MBVideo exhibits
Exhibit CA-19(2): Exhibit JB-1: Video taken on 12 January 2025
Exhibit CA-19(4): Exhibit JB-3: Video taken of 3 Penny Lane on 14 January 2025
Exhibit CA-19(5): Exhibit JB-4: Video taken of water flowing on 14 January 2025
Exhibit CA-19(11): Exhibit JB-10: Video taken of kerbs on Prospect Hill Road on 15 January 2025
Exhibit CA-19(12): Exhibit JB-11: Video taken of kerbs along Prospect Hill Road on 15 January 2025
Exhibit CA-19(13): Exhibit JB-12: Video taken of kerbs on Prospect Hill Road on 15 January 2025
Exhibit CA-19(19): Exhibit JB-18: Video taken near burst site on 20 February 2025
Exhibit CA-19(20): Exhibit JB-19: Video taken near burst site on 20 February 2025
Exhibit CA-19(21): Exhibit JB-20: Video taken near burst site on 20 February 2025
Email - Gerrard Borghesi to Maw Civil Marine
Exhibit MPSC-1: Email from G Borghesi to Maw Civil Marine Pty Ltd dated 18 October 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 76.67 KBVideo - Wet soil and water, Borghesi
Video - Escarpment and dust from 3 Penny Lane
Video - Soil falling down escarpment and 3 Penny Lane debris
Video - Soil and mud down escarpment, Borghesi
Witness Statement - Lara Olsen, South East Water
Exhibit CA-25(1): Witness Statement of Lara Olsen, Managing Director of South East Water dated 30 April 2025 (signed 16 May 2025)(opens in a new window)PDF 3.21 MBDiagrams - South East Water infrastructure
Exhibit CA-25(2): Exhibits 1a and 1b - SEW infrastructure responsibility sewerage and water infrastructure diagrams, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 434.21 KBOrganisational Structure - South East Water
Exhibit CA-25(3): Exhibit 2 - South East Water Organisational Structure as at April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 190.13 KBContract Register
Exhibit CA-25(4): Exhibit 3 - Contract register, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 64.24 KBLeak Detection - South East Water
Exhibit CA-25(5): Exhibit 4 - South East Water Acoustic Leak Detection, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 66.86 KBTask Summary (document in three parts) - South East Water
Exhibit CA-26(1) and SEW-02(1): South East Water Tasks Summary in relation to water leaks at McCrae, various dates(opens in a new window)PDF 68.35 MBExhibit CA-26(1) and SEW-02(1): South East Water Tasks Summary in relation to water leaks at McCrae, various dates(opens in a new window)PDF 53.98 MBExhibit CA-26(1) and SEW-02(1): South East Water Tasks Summary in relation to water leaks at McCrae, various dates(opens in a new window)PDF 57.82 MBTask Summary - South East Water
Exhibit CA-26(2) and SEW-02(2): Task Summary 1290137 in relation to 1 Charlesworth Street, McCrae dated 28 November 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 18.39 MBPlanned Maintenance Repair - South East Water
Exhibit CA-26(3) and SEW-02(3): Planned Maintenance Repair - 32 Coburn Avenue McCrae dated 29 December 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 8.47 MBSMEC Report
Exhibit CA-27: SMEC Report dated 5 May 2025 titled McCrae Landslip Project(opens in a new window)PDF 19.94 MBEmail regarding Bayview Road burst - South East Water
Exhibit CA-28: Email correspondence between South East Water regarding burst in Bayview Road, McCrae dated 24 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.7 MBSubmission - South East Water
Exhibit CA-29(1): South East Water Submission to the Board of Inquiry into the McCrae Landslide, dated April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.22 MBSubmission - Plan showing South East Water network
Exhibit CA-29(2): Exhibit 1 to SEW Submission - Plan showing water mains network contained in submission provided by South East Water, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 609.18 KBSubmission - Plan showing South East Water network
Exhibit CA-29(3): Exhibit 2 to SEW Submission - Plan showing sewerage network around vicinity of the Landslide site, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 621.5 KBInternal email - South East Water
Exhibit CA-30: Internal email correspondence of South East Water regarding analysis of night flow data at Waller Place, McCrae between 16 January 2025 and 22 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 2.41 MBExhibits CA-31:
First witness statement of David Smith dated 17 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.75 MBRoads Corridor Contract No. 2635 between the Shire and Fulton Hogan, dated 15 December 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 2.19 MBEmail from Mornington Shire Council to Downer Group regarding Board of Inquiry request for information dated 14 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 161.67 KBLetter from Downer Group to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding request for information to support McCrae Board of Inquiry dated 15 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 103.25 KBSpreadsheet provided by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council reporting defects and completed works between 19 November 2020 and 6 October 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 42.62 KBExcel Spreadsheet detailing Invoices for Account 'K&C View Point Road McCrae', undated(opens in a new window)PDF 95.2 KBSpreadsheet of Mornington Shire Council works completed in McCrae between 19 August 2016 to 14 March 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 146.41 KBImage of road at unknown location, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 209.62 KBImage of road (undated)(opens in a new window)PDF 143.53 KBImage of drain (undated)(opens in a new window)PDF 351.45 KBImage of cracked floor/road (undated)(opens in a new window)PDF 466.89 KBImage of damaged tree (undated)(opens in a new window)PDF 401.8 KBImage of road and damaged tree (undated)(opens in a new window)PDF 165.58 KBImage of nature strip (undated)(opens in a new window)PDF 259.21 KBImage of road and nature strip with works (undated)(opens in a new window)PDF 294.07 KBImage of damaged road dated 15 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 314.64 KBSpreadsheet of Action Items for Mornington Peninsula Shire Council from 2018 to 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 87.41 KBImage of pipe going into ground dated 15 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 612.89 KBImage of road works dated 15 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 348.36 KBImage of pot hole at Waller Place undated(opens in a new window)PDF 207.79 KBEmail correspondence within Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding road surface conditions at Coburn Avenue dated 12 April 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 837.5 KBImage of damaged road, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 176.2 KBImage of driveway covered in debris undated(opens in a new window)PDF 283.03 KBImage of road with sign 'Traffic Hazard', undated(opens in a new window)PDF 369.75 KBImage of covered pothole, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 313.36 KBImage of damaged road, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 378.96 KBImage of pothole with safety cone, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 208.63 KBImage of opened drain, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 597.54 KBImage of drain with pit lid damage, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 255.53 KBSpreadsheet of Work Orders received by Mornington Peninsula Shire Council in relation to Charlesworth Street, Prospect Hill Road, View Point Road, and others dating between 6 August 2024 and 27 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 86.7 KBImage of pit drain, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 661.13 KBImage of damaged road, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 199.54 KBImage of open pit drain filled with water, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 728.18 KBPhoto of drainage pipe works, dated 2 December 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 774.34 KBEmail chain between Mornington Peninsula Shire Council and Fulton Hogan regarding maintenance of works in exclusion area dated 16 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 329.2 KBPhoto of patched road, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 401.45 KBImage of fixed pit drain, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 332.12 KBImages outlining work on Charlesworth Street and Waller Place Pits and places with water issues observed, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 836.27 KBImage of water coming through the ground, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 361.46 KBImage of water coming through pot hole, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 406.28 KBImage of water coming through road, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 303.1 KBImage of damaged pit drain, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 254.92 KBEmail correspondence between Fulton Hogan and Mornington Peninsula Shire Council forwarding details of works dated 16 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 309.06 KBImage of pit drain, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 285.53 KBWater along curb, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 743.92 KBImage of obstructed pit drain, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 343.85 KBImage of water along curb, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 359 KBImage of Road with traffic hazard sign, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 411.96 KBImage of pot hole, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 207.79 KBEmail correspondence between TDG Environmental and DM Roads regarding works at 2 View Point Road, dated 12 September 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 232.58 KBCCTV Inspection report for View Point Road, dated 30 August 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 326.65 KBCCTV Inspection Report for 7 Prospect Hill Road, dated 30 August 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 1.08 MBMcCrae Information Request, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 47.72 KBSecond witness statement of David Smith dated 30 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 598.51 KBAnnexures to Second Statement, dated 30 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 5.37 MBRoads Corridor Contract No. 2635 between the Shire and Fulton Hogan, dated 15 December 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 2.19 MBEmail from Fulton Hogan to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council enclosing interactions between South East Water, dated 24 April 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 122.26 KBJK and South East Water interactions dated 31 December 2024 to 6 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 154.26 KBEmail from Fulton Hogan to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding ongoing water issues at Charlesworth Street, dated 2 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 129.36 KBImages taken on about 21 January 2025 depicting Burst Water Main area(opens in a new window)PDF 267.68 KBImages taken on about 21 January 2025 depicting Burst Water Main area(opens in a new window)PDF 462.87 KBImages taken on about 21 January 2025 depicting Burst Water Main area(opens in a new window)PDF 273.77 KBImages taken on about 21 January 2025 depicting Burst Water Main area(opens in a new window)PDF 289.7 KBWork order request for investigation of spoon drains at Penny Lane, dated 16 December 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 63.08 KBMap of site observations at proximity of Burst Water Main, dated 22 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 548.6 KBPhotographs at the intersection of Coburn Avenue and Charlesworth Street, dated 21 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 239.45 KBPhotographs at the intersection of Coburn Avenue and Charlesworth Street, dated 21 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 240.13 KBPhotographs at the intersection of Coburn Avenue and Charlesworth Street, dated 21 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 212.05 KBPhotograph of works in progress at Charlesworth Street, dated 16 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 243.67 KBPhotograph of works in progress at Coburn Avenue, dated 18 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 329.61 KBEmail correspondence and meeting invitation between South East Water and Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding Charlesworth Street, dated 28 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.84 MBThird witness statement of David Smith dated 11 June 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.4 MBNovember 2022 Road Openings Report(opens in a new window)Excel 21.65 KBEmail correspondence between South East Water to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council enclosing Road Openings Detail Report dated 1 December 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 53.01 KBShire’s Asset Management Policy, dated 26 August 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 2.36 MBAsset Management Strategy 2020-2030(opens in a new window)PDF 3.65 MBStormwater Asset Management Plan, dated September 2020(opens in a new window)PDF 2.71 MBFlood and Stormwater Strategy, dated May 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 670.04 KBDeed of Novation, Variation and Extension, dated 30 June 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 818.78 KBDeed of Extension and Variation, dated 4 May 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 1.28 MBRoads Corridor Contract between Fulton Hogan and Shire, dated 15 December 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 2.19 MBAnnexure 4 to the Roads Corridor Contract(opens in a new window)PDF 2.05 MBAppendix 1 to the Road Management Plan, dated September 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 1.42 MBPhotographs taken of the kerb and channel on View Point Road during site visit in 2019(opens in a new window)PDF 93.12 KBPhotographs taken of the kerb and channel on View Point Road during site visit in 2019(opens in a new window)PDF 110.57 KBPhotographs taken of the kerb and channel on View Point Road during site visit in 2019(opens in a new window)PDF 99.93 KBPhotographs taken of the kerb and channel on View Point Road during site visit in 2019(opens in a new window)PDF 122.55 KBPhotographs taken of the kerb and channel on View Point Road during site visit in 2019(opens in a new window)PDF 94.44 KBPhotographs taken of the kerb and channel on View Point Road during site visit in 2019(opens in a new window)PDF 89.43 KBDesign for the stormwater drainage upgrade, dated May 2021(opens in a new window)PDF 589.88 KBKerb and Channell Renewal Program for financial year 2022-2023(opens in a new window)PDF 77.41 KBPurchase Order dated 26 October 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 101.74 KBPurchase Order, dated 24 October 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 111.67 KBCustomer Requests between October 2024 and January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 231.4 KBStormwater CCTV inspection report for View Point Road, dated 15 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.44 MBPurchase Order, dated 26 October 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 101.74 KBCleansing and Drainage Cleaning Contract dated 1 December 2018 (1 of 2 files)(opens in a new window)PDF 16.77 MBCleansing and Drainage Cleaning Contract dated 1 December 2018 (2 of 2 files)(opens in a new window)PDF 17.18 MBKerb renewal project for 2020-2021 financial year(opens in a new window)PDF 175.53 KBExhibits CA-32:
Witness Statement of Claudio Flores dated 22 May 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 174.81 KBEmail correspondence between Mornington Shire Council and Cardno regarding Emergency Orders dated 15 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 466.62 KBNotice cancelling the order to vacate 10-12 View Point Road, 18 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 125.43 KBNotice cancelling the order to vacate 14-16 View Point Road, 18 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 175.34 KBNotice cancelling the order to vacate 3 Penny Lane, 18 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 109.99 KBEmergency Order (EO-152/22) 10-12 View Point Rd – prohibiting entry and use of land within 3m of the embarkment, 18 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 778.91 KBEmergency Order (EO-153/22) 10-12 View Point Rd – engage geotechnical engineer to assess site and provide recommendations for make safe work, 28 November 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 218.67 KBStantec Report 2022 Landslide, 7 December 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 2.71 MBBuilding Order for Minor Works (MW-127/23) 10-12 View Point Rd – retaining walls or other site stabilisation walls, 28 March 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 227.66 KBEmail correspondence between G Borghesi and C Flores regarding void under kerb and channel on View Point Rd, 11 May 2023 to 17 May 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 142.04 KBPSM Expert Opinion Report – Landslide Assessment in relation to 10-12 View Point Road, dated 11 June 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 8.63 MBBuilding Notice (No. BN-001/24) 10-12 View Point Rd – show cause as to why no stabiliation work should occur, 7 February 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 253.44 KBBuilding Order - (No. BO-004/24) 10-12 View Point Rd – stabilisation work, 4 April 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 243.88 KBHarwood Andrews – Letter of Instruction to PSM for landslide characterisation of escarpment, 24 January 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 158.42 KBImage of the escarpment that Mr Pope has been asked to characterize, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 529.86 KBExhibit CA-33:
Email from Ben and Ann Wells to Mornington Peninsula Shire Council regarding water running off the hill at Penny Lane from View Point Road dated 17 February 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 100.16 KBExhibits CA-34:
Witness Statement of Katanya Barlow dated 20 June 2025 (CA-34)(opens in a new window)PDF 2.6 MBMornington Peninsula Shire Minutes Council Meeting – Tuesday 14 May 2019, 7pm: Municipal Offices Besgrove Street, Rosebud(opens in a new window)PDF 348.01 KBMornington Peninsula Shire Attachments of Council Meeting – Tuesday 14 May 2019, 7pm: Municipal Offices Besgrove Street, Rosebud(opens in a new window)PDF 13.83 MBMornington Peninsula Shire Minutes – Planning Services Committee Meeting – Monday 16 March 2020, 7pm(opens in a new window)PDF 840.6 KBMornington Peninsula Shire Minutes – Planning Services Committee Meeting – Monday 16 March 2020, 7pm(opens in a new window)PDF 776.67 KBEmail from Christian Lynch to DELWP re comments for draft Bushfire Planning Provisions(opens in a new window)PDF 255.56 KBMornington Peninsula Shire Agenda – Council Meeting on Tuesday 19 December, 2023, 6:30pm(opens in a new window)PDF 2.65 MBMornington Peninsula Shire Agenda – Council Meeting on Tuesday 19 December, 2023, 6:30pm(opens in a new window)PDF 4.28 MBMornington Peninsula Shire Minutes – Planning Services Committee Meeting on Monday, 28 March 2022 at 5:30pm(opens in a new window)PDF 1.06 MBMornington Peninsula Shire Minutes – Council Meeting on Tuesday 19 December, 2023, 6:30pm(opens in a new window)PDF 538.42 KBLetter to Hon. Sonya Kilkenny on 28 March 2024 re Bushfire Planning Provisions - Review and Pilot Project(opens in a new window)PDF 232.1 KBEmail to Katanya Barlow re follow ups from meeting on 1 May(opens in a new window)PDF 119.96 KBLetter to Hon B. Cameron MP on 28 September 2001 re absence of legislative power or regulation to deal with unstable land in residential areas(opens in a new window)PDF 566.22 KBLetter to Mr Alex Atkins on 15 November 2001 re the absence of legislative power or regulation to deal with unstable land in residential areas(opens in a new window)PDF 255.53 KBLetter to the Hon Sonya Kilkenny on 22 August 2023 re State Government Coastal Hazard Planning Controls(opens in a new window)PDF 417.21 KBMornington Peninsula Shire Agenda for Council Meeting on Tuesday, 11 July 2023 at 10am(opens in a new window)PDF 1.23 MBMornington Peninsula Minutes for Council Meeting held on Tuesday, 11 July, 2023 at 10am(opens in a new window)PDF 770.56 KBReforming Victoria’s Planning System – Local Government Sector Submission(opens in a new window)PDF 2.1 MBMornington Peninsula Shire Agenda for Council Meeting held on Tuesday, 6 May, 2025 at 6:30pm(opens in a new window)PDF 545.04 KBMornington Peninsula Shire Minutes of Council Meeting held on Tuesday, 6 May 2025 at 6:30pm(opens in a new window)PDF 423.08 KBEmail from Katanya Barlow re townhouse code and inability to now consider known environmental hazards not in the planning scheme(opens in a new window)PDF 109.63 KBDirection No. 15 The Planning Scheme Amendment Process(opens in a new window)PDF 149.57 KBInternational society for Soil Mechanisms and Geotechnical Engineering – ‘Gig Assessment of Regional Landslide Susceptibility, Mornington Peninsula Shire’(opens in a new window)PDF 2.38 MB- Exhibit CA-35: First Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd of South East Water dated 4 June 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 414.39 KBExhibit CA-35(1): First Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd of South East Water dated 4 June 2025, Exhibit 1: Leak Detection Prioritisation Tool 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 283.96 KBExhibit CA-35(2): First Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd of South East Water dated 4 June 2025, Exhibit 2: Draft procedure for investigation unknown water sources, dated 29 May 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 772.67 KBExhibit CA-35(3): First Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd of South East Water dated 4 June 2025, Exhibit 3: South East Water Summary of monitoring and maintenance work done during this event titled ‘Monitoring and Maintenance in McCrae' dated 29 May 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 1.1 MBExhibit CA-35(4): First Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd of South East Water dated 4 June 2025, Exhibit 4: South East Water internal email correspondence regarding investigation of sources of water coming out of the ground in McCrae dated 14 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 241.65 KBExhibit CA-35(5): First Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd of South East Water dated 4 June 2025, Exhibit 5: South East Water internal email correspondence regarding leak at 12 Coburn Avenue dated 21 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 357.25 KBExhibit CA-35(6): First Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd of South East Water dated 4 June 2025, Exhibit 6: South East Water internal email correspondence regarding summary of water sample testing dated 16 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 341.75 KBExhibit CA-35(7): First Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd of South East Water dated 4 June 2025, Exhibit 7: South East Water internal email correspondence regarding night flow analysis for Waller Place dated 16 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 654.32 KBExhibit CA-35(8): First Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd of South East Water dated 4 June 2025, Exhibit 8: Map annotated by South East Water identifying water mains where leak detection was performed, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 189.01 KBExhibit CA-35(9): First Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd of South East Water dated 4 June 2025, Exhibit 9: South East Water internal correspondence regarding night flow analysis in McCrae dated from 20 January 2025 to 22 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 769.67 KBExhibit CA-35(10): First Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd of South East Water dated 4 June 2025, Exhibit 10: South East Water internal email correspondence regarding night flow analysis dated from 20 January 2025 to 22 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 668.66 KBExhibit CA-35(11): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 601.17 KBExhibit CA-35(12): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 1: South East Water extract of tasks relating to water network in McCrae dated from 19 July 2024 to 20 May 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 88.86 KBExhibit CA-35(13): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 2: South East Water extract of tasks relating to sewer network in McCrae dated from 2 August 2023 to 5 June 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 107.97 KBExhibit CA-35(15): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 4: Maintenance Services Agreement between South East Water and Service Stream Maintenance Pty Ltd dated 29 April 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 6.02 MBExhibit CA-35(16): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 5: South East Water Inspection Procedure for Service Stream dated 22 August 2022(opens in a new window)PDF 347.64 KBExhibit CA-35(17): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 6: Downer Work Instruction for Water Mains and Repair Leaks Work, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 263.35 KBExhibit CA-35(18): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 7: User Manual for EC-TDS Pen dated January 2023(opens in a new window)PDF 292.96 KBExhibit CA-35(19): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 8: Basic User Manual - EC-TDS Pen(opens in a new window)PDF 496.59 KBExhibit CA-35(20): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 9: Image of Pocket Pro Low Range Conductivity Tester undated(opens in a new window)PDF 108.58 KBExhibit CA-35(21): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 10: Fuji Digital Sound Detector Instruction Manual, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 825.25 KBExhibit CA-35(22): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 11: ALS water sample quality control report prepared for South East Water dated 4 February 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 96.28 KBExhibit CA-35(23): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 12: Agreement for the Provision of Services (One off) between South East Water and Detection Services Pty Ltd dated 5 May 2020(opens in a new window)PDF 579.28 KBExhibit CA-35(24): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 13: Leak Detection Zone Prioritisation Tool 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 283.96 KBExhibit CA-35(25): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 14: Spreadsheet provided by Detection Services Pty Ltd dated between 20 March 2025 to 31 March 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 65.45 KBExhibit CA-35(26): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 15: Exhibit 4 to the Witness Statement of Lara Olsen titled Acoustic Leak Detection document, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 98.52 KBExhibit CA-35(27): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 16: South East Water Faults Diagnosis Guide, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 76.5 KBExhibit CA-35(28): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 17: South East Water Water Main Faults Guide, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 785.63 KBExhibit CA-35(29): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 18: South East Service Pipe Faults Guide(opens in a new window)PDF 519.63 KBExhibit CA-35(30): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 19: South East Water instruction guide for responding to injuries, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 41.64 KBExhibit CA-35(31): Second Witness Statement of Tim Lloyd dated 10 June 2025, Exhibit 20: South East Water guide for handling water leak jobs in McCrae, undated(opens in a new window)PDF 436.89 KBExhibit CA-36(1): SEW internal email correspondence regarding water leaks in McCrae dated 14 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 497.85 KBExhibit CA-36(2): Observations from Site Visit(opens in a new window)PDF 368.67 KBExhibit MPSC-2: Email correspondence within South East Water regarding McCrae water usage comparisons dated 16 January 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 347.63 KBExhibit CA-37: Witness statement of Jason Marsh dated 4 June 2025(opens in a new window)PDF 299.31 KBExhibit CA-37(1): Witness statement of Jason Marsh dated 4 June 2025, Exhibit 1: Detection Services leak report prepared for South East Water regarding 4 Waller Place dated 24 December 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 1.12 MBExhibit CA-37(2): Witness statement of Jason Marsh dated 4 June 2025, Exhibit 2: Internal South East Water email correspondence regarding leak at 4 Waller Place dated 24 December 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 247.62 KBExhibit CA-37(3): Witness statement of Jason Marsh dated 4 June 2025, Exhibit 3: Photograph of letter box at 3 Charlesworth St taken by J Marsh on 27 December 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 540.99 KBExhibit CA-37(4): Witness statement of Jason Marsh dated 4 June 2025, Exhibit 4: Photograph of intersection of Charlesworth St and Waller Place taken by J Marsh on 27 December 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 256.27 KBExhibit CA-37(5): Witness statement of Jason Marsh dated 4 June 2025, Exhibit 5: Photograph taken near 27 Charlesworth Street by J Marsh on 27 December 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 371.3 KBExhibit CA-39(9): Internal SEW correspondence regarding reported leak at 4 Waller Place dated from 24 December 2024 to 30 December 2024(opens in a new window)PDF 1.73 MB
Updated